Wrestler of the Year
– CM Punk
– Austin Aries
– Adam Cole
– Bobby Roode

Tag Team of the Year
– Kofi Kingston & R-Truth
– Team Hell No
– Bad Influence (Kazarian & Christopher Daniels)
– Super Smash Brothers

Mark Out Moment of the Year
– Brock Lesnar Returning
– Paul Heyman and CM Punk teaming up
– Attending WrestleMania
– Brandon dressing up as Mankind for Halloween

Female Wrestler of the Year
– Miss. Tessmacher
– AJ Lee
– Eve Torres
– Gail Kim

Event of the Year
– WWE Extreme Rules
– WWE WrestleMania
– PWS 5th Anniversary
– TNA Bound For Glory

Match of the Year
– Adam Cole vs Kyle O’Reily (ROH Best in the World: Hostage Crisis)
– James Storm vs Bobby Roode (TNA Bound of Glory)
– Sami Callihan & Anthony Nese vs The Great Muta & KAI (PWS 5 Year Anniversary)
– Undertaker vs Triple H (WWE WrestleMania 28)

Breakout Star of the Year
– Adam Cole
– Daniel Bryan
– Ryback
– The Big O

Feud of the Year
– CM Punk vs Chris Jericho
– CM Punk vs John Cena
– CHIKARA vs GEKIDO
– John Laurinaitis vs WWE